Golfers who are not members of the club, and to whom the ban does not apply, turned out to play on Sunday while members who could be expelled for breaking the club rule looked on enviously. Stornoway Golf Club confirmed that it will now consider going to court to overturn the never-on-a-Sunday rule which is more than 100 years old. The club has already had counsel’s opinion that the Sunday ban is illegal and may also breach human rights laws.
Club secretary Ken Galloway said that in December the members said they wanted talks with the trust for seven-day golf and they also agreed to give the trust the legal opinion they had got in support of their bid. In the event of refusal of the request, the members of the club had instructed the management committee to proceed immediately to arbitration.
Mr Galloway explained: “Having received the trust’s statement that they are “not inclined to accede” to our request for seven-day golf, the management committee of Stornoway Golf Club will meet on April 17, after which we will consult our legal advisers about the way forward.”
Last year, at the club’s annual general meeting, a vote was taken where only four out of 130 members voted for the status quo. There were a number who did not vote. A previous attempt to persuade the publicly-owned Stornoway Trust to lift the ban failed two years ago. Now the legal opinion, which is understood to suggest that the trust may be breaching human rights legislation, has bolstered the drive to change the ruling among many members and their supporters.
On Sunday morning, club member Fred Maclennan, who is 69, a former club captain, had to stay off the course while his friend, learner golfer Colin Maclean, practised on the tee. Fred, a retired telephone engineer, explained: “As a member of this club, I believe I would be expelled if I broke the Sunday ban. I dare not go onto the course because of the ban imposed on the club and its members by Stornoway Trust. But Colin and his friends are not members and are not bound by any club rules – so they can play on the course as much as they want.
“The strange thing is that I am allowed to play golf anywhere else on Stornoway Trust land on Sunday – just not on the golf course. It is a crazy situation. You could not make it up.”
Fred said that Sunday golf would not disturb anyone else. He said the golf club was being respectful to local customs and traditions adding that although the club has a seven-day drinks licence, the members have decided not to open the bar on Sundays because of that respect.
Roofing contractor Colin Maclean is far from happy that, while he is allowed to play as much as he wants, his old pal Fred must stay outside the gate or be expelled. He said: “It is a disgrace which shows up the farce in this town for what it really is. Several pubs are open so it is okay to go in town and drink and get slaughtered but not a healthy game of golf which is banned on pain of expulsion. The people responsible for this are the same people who lock up the sports facilities and are forcing our young people into the pubs.
“Do the Lord’s Day Observance Society (LDOS) people who we hear are now installed on the trust and have brought this daft situation about have consciences at all? I don’t really think they do”
Some members of a local football team said they were heading for a Stornoway pub on Sunday lunchtime because they said they were not allowed to practise anywhere on the Sunday. “We are going to the pub basically because we are not allowed to do any of the sporting things we would really want to do. We are going to the pub because the LDOS won’t let us do anything else. I haven’t found it but it must be in the bible somewhere that being healthy is wrong and against God’s will,” said one of them, who asked not to be named because someone in his own family is a church office-bearer.
Stornoway Trust is steadfastly refusing to explain the reasons for the refusal to lift the Sunday ban on the golf club and its members. Its factor would only say: “The trust considers this to be a private matter between landlord and tenant. It would therefore be inappropriate for me to offer any comments on the issue.” The Lord’s Day Observance Society reaction to non-club members turning up to play golf on the Sabbath is not known as its officers do not take calls from the media on Sunday.
The trust was formed in 1923 after soap king Lord Leverhulme bought the island of Lewis for £150,000. He then gifted Lews Castle and its 64,000 acres of land to Stornoway parish residents and the trust was set up to run the estate for the community. The golf club came into being in 1890. It was firstly on the site of Stornoway Airport until it was requisitioned for the war effort. The club got £9,600 to set up another 18-hole course and clubhouse and opened in 1947 in Lady Lever Park, in the grounds of the castle.