Category Archives: MSP

Read what really happened in that office in Dunfermline last Monday.

Paul Hutcheon
Investigations Editor, Sunday Herald
Sunday 15 September 2013
.

WIFE-beater Bill Walker endorsed a “disgraceful” statement attacking one of his abuse victims, according to a leaked conversation with his former spin doctor.

Walker also claimed his “constituents” supported him, said people wondered why his wives had not come forward sooner, and revealed he was already working on an appeal.

Elected as the SNP MSP for Dunfermline in 2011, Walker finally quit Holyrood eight days ago after being found guilty of 23 charges of assault.

The violence included attacks on three ex-wives and a teenage step-daughter. On Monday, the saga reached farcical proportions after his media adviser Iain Maciver released a statement mocking ­Walker’s third wife, Diana.

It described her as a “former TV walk-on artist” who was “enjoying the limelight again in front of the cameras”.

The statement questioned why, if she had been “subject to as much abuse as she now claims”, she did not divorce Walker. Maciver withdrew the press release, apologised to Mrs Walker and told STV he blamed himself for the error.

“I knew straight away that was inappropriate, it was flippant, that wasn’t the form of statement that I expected to send or wanted to send,” he said.

“Mr Bill Walker did not write that statement. He left it to me to clarify matters about their divorce and the result is all my fault.”

Maciver resigned as Walker’s PR spokesman hours later. However, notes of a conversation between Walker and Maciver on Thursday cast a different light on the press release.

During a tense 20-minute exchange, Maciver told Walker his friends were “puzzled why I took the rap”, adding that the truth was Walker had told him “the stuff” about his ex-wife and “you approved it”.

Walker replied saying the ­statement “went out in your name”, but noted: “I did see what you sent out before it went out and, you know, the facts were correct. It was done in your style. The facts were correct.”

Maciver said the statement, which he said was sent from Walker’s former constituency office, “was all subject to negotiation up until the end when you said ‘okay, send that’.”

Walker replied: “Well, I said it was alright with me and don’t know if I said …”

Maciver returned to the theme, claiming that “I trashed my own reputation for something that I am ultimately not responsible for.”

Walker was unmoved: “Well, I suppose you’re responsible for what you issue and I certainly thought the facts were right.”

The pair repeatedly clashed about whether Walker had “approved” the statement, a word to which the former MSP objected. Maciver said to Walker: “Come on. I think you’re in denial about many things.”

Back on the subject of the statement, Walker said: “I saw it before you issued it. Yes.” Maciver replied: “You not only saw it, you sat down and you said ‘that’s fine’.”

Walker again quibbled: “Can’t remember the words …”

More broadly, Walker claimed people in Dunfermline supported him: “We had one woman this ­morning, a friend – well, not a friend, a constituent … saying … why did they suddenly come forward 20, 30, 40 years later?

“And that sort of view is ­surfacing all the time but, of course, these are the small people.”

He also said: “Constituents are saying to the girls … these women should have come out years ago if they had anything to complain – why now?” He added: “It’ll all be part of the appeal.”

After Maciver said it was ­”obviously the end of the road for me and you”, the conversation ended. Walker is to be sentenced on Friday.

Maciver told the Sunday Herald yesterday: “Bill Walker took me into his PA’s office and told me what to write, insisting it had all been aired in court. I advised him against it.

“Just before we left to catch my train at Inverkeithing, he demanded his name be removed and he hung me out to dry. There was no alternative for me but to claim it was my mistake, grovel and take the abuse until I could clear my name. Without witnesses, I had no way to prove I had been set up until the facts came from his own lips.”

Scottish Conservative deputy leader Jackson Carlaw said: “If it’s the case that Bill Walker did know about this disgraceful release, then that is yet another staggering low.

“He’s gone from denying his guilt to almost revelling in it, and that is only making things worse for his victims.”

Labour MSP Claire Baker said: “This is more evidence, if any more was needed, that Bill Walker should never have been selected by the SNP to stand for the Scottish Parliament.

“After lying to the court about his behaviour, we now learn that there are more lies about his involvement in this disgraceful attack on one of his victims.

“The fact that he believes that the people of Dunfermline support him is another example of how detached he has become from reality.”

Walker did not return this newspaper’s telephone call.

Secret recording reveals Bill Walker’s PR man deliberately faked grovelling TV apology

Sunday Herald

Exclusive

‘Bill Walker approved disastrous press release’

Iain Maciver said tonight: “I took all the blame on national TV and in the press, and the torrent of horrendous personal abuse that followed which almost finished me and my family, until I could catch out the real culprit. There was nothing else I could do with honour.”

Reminder from last Monday - Tory leader Ruth Davidson said: “These comments from Bill Walker’s PR man are a disgusting coda to a shameful set of actions.”

Some interesting local Facebook reaction last Monday:

Bill Walker’s media spokesman admits MSP’s statement is ‘PR disaster’
news.stv.tv
Iain Maciver apologised to Diana Walker over the media release.
  • 9 people like this.
  • Bill Greig Oh dear. He’s PR’s version of the Titanic without the style and class.
  • Paul Pia It is an indictment of our political system that a man like that was chosen as a candidate – what was the selection committee thinking about?
  • Ali MacKay Saw him on news last night, watched in disbelief. Clown.
  • Angus Mackay He appears to think that it was only the fact that he sent it that was wrong……
  • John MacLeod Iain X Maciver is a well known personality in the Western Isles… we’ll leave it there. But even the TV appearance is a disaster; I had an excessively exciting month in a similar and impossible role for Western Isles Health Board in 2006 – at a time when its affairs resembled downtown Beirut in the mid-1980s – and had to do the odd bit of ‘crisis PR’ telly. I had the wits to insist on nice out-of-doors locales, to be interviewed standing and to wear a suit and tie… Iain is slumped, slovenly dressed, and with the air of a man helping the police with their inquiries. Amateur Hour.
  • Orica MacDonald It wasn’t far of trending today. Poor show.
  • John MacLeod Aye. For his many admirers on Lewis, it would take a heart of stone not to laugh… no one has done more, locally, over the last two decades to bring journalism into disrepute.
  • Betsy Martin At least The churches are getting respite while he is involved in this burach !
  • Bill Greig It is a measure of Mr Walker that he used Mr Maciver as his spokesman.
  • John MacLeod Indeed. Scotland Tonight just reported Mr Maciver as a ‘self-proclaimed PR expert.’ *purred* *extended claws*
  • Domhnall Ruadh Poor Iain X. You have to admit, though, that he is a dab hand with the shovel….
  • John MacLeod As in, when you’re in a hole, stop digging? (Or not, as evidenced here.) This man has hurt, defamed and destroyed so many people over so many years that I find myself suffering a serious dose of compassion-fatigue… I shall bear it bravely.
  • Chrissie Smith Uh! John. Has he any admirers in Lewis?
  • John MacLeod He has some, unfortunately; nowhere in Britain are Christians more in evidence than they are here, but nowhere else are they more hated. He has largely built his career on painting the picture of an island under the fist of so many Ayatollahs, and – unfortunately – there is a market for it.
  • Magz Macleod He’s sorry he sent the wrong message out? How about an apology for describing Mrs Walker in the most derogatory terms? Whatever the ins and outs of this case, Mr Maciver’s performance, both in terms of his initial publication and subsequent ‘apology’…See More
  • John MacLeod Well, I think we all knew his character already, up here. Hopefully this will be an eyeopener for the papers hereto so happy to run his material, consult him on Western Isles stories and listen to his boozy smears against people he doesn’t like.
  • Magz Macleod So he deliberately smears a woman who has already been brutalized by her husband. What a ‘gentleman’ – not
  • Domhnall Ruadh I did indeed john mean to salute the sheer indefatigueability of his forearms in this regard..
    Cheskin

OHCG wants urgent summit to discuss way forward after SNP killed commercial RET

OUTER HEBRIDES COMMERCE GROUP

Angus Campbell
Comhairle Nan Eilean Siar
Sandwick Road
Stornoway
Isle of Lewis

April 29 2013

Dear Angus 

I wish to thank you and the majority of your colleagues for supporting the Outer Hebrides Commerce Group in our campaign opposing the removal of affordable ferry fares for commercial vehicles to and from our islands. 

The publication last Friday of the Scottish Government sponsored investigation into the removal of “RET” was a clear vindication of what many of us have been saying for over a year. 

The economic ruination being visited on our families and communities cannot be over stated. We have for the first time, a clear, unambiguous and creditable analysis of the impact the SNP Government’s flawed ferry policy has on all currently living and working in our islands. 

On behalf of the OHCG I would respectfully request that the Comhairle urgently agrees to host a seminar to discuss this report; how we can continue campaigning in a consistent and coherent manner, on ferry fares and also the implications of the removal of the Air Discount Scheme. 

It would be reasonable to expect that our MP and MSP would attend along with representatives from Highlands and Islands Enterprise. The consultants from MVA consultancy who undertook the study should also be invited to set the scene, and outline their main findings. 

The OHCG is due to meet with Angus Brendan MacNeil MP at the end of next week. In the meantime, he is gong to share with us all the letters he sent on behalf of his constituents and the letters he received from the Transport Minister. 

I look forward to your response. 

David Wood
Vice-Chairperson
Outer Hebrides Commerce Group

Comhairle rubbishes “incorrect” claims by MP and MSP about axing of Friday morning flights from Edinburgh

Claims by Angus Macneil MP and Alasdair Allan MSP that Loganair is stopping Edinburgh to Stornoway flights on Friday mornings because of the council’s decision on axing inter-island air services have not gone down well in the Whitehouse. Not well at all.

“People here have been spitting feathers,” said my mole by the water-cooler.flybe

When he read what the SNP were saying, council leader Angus Campbell blew a fuse. He rushed into the office today to tell everyone who would listen that Loganair had confirmed to them that the reason for stopping the service on a Friday morning was down to how few people were using the service and nothing at all to do with planes not being available.

When services are stopped, more planes become available, not less. Where did the SNP slaggers-off get all that stuff from? Campbell really would like to know. I think we all would.

After wiping the feathery down from his mouth, he grabbed a pen and scribbled a note which was then officially released saying: “It is a commercial decision and on this occasion, unfortunately, our MP and MSP are completely incorrect. The loss of the Friday morning service is similar to commercial decisions taken on other routes and is entirely due to the consistently low number of passengers.”

For the record, there is no suggestion from anyone that anyone else was telling porkies – just that they were “incorrect” – or as the Campbell fellow shouted in the corridor, “completely incorrect”. Oh flip. That guy’s boiling up.

As if that was not enough, the executive office kept up the onslaught by then firing out a copy of a statement from Phil Preston, the big chief at the top of Loganair. He was quoted as saying: “It is with regret that due to consistently-low passenger numbers Loganair has been forced to make a commercial decision to withdraw the Friday morning service between Edinburgh and Stornoway.”

So that is another wee confusion sorted out. Put down the guns. Have a strong coffee, or something. You too in Bayhead.

Oh, look. Pinned on the end of his statement, high-flyer Phil had put a bit of good news which says: “We have however introduced a new direct Monday morning service between Stornoway and Edinburgh, departing the Isle of Lewis at 8.50am and arriving in the capital at 10am, 30 minutes earlier than the current schedule.”

When he emerged from the cool, dark room where he had a wee rest to calm down, Angus Campbell described the new Monday morning flights as “a welcome move”.

Right, that’s the excitement over. Now get on with your work.

Stornoway to lose morning air link to Edinburgh on Fridays – comhairle blamed as islands lose out with 21 flights a week axed

Loganair is to stop morning flights between Edinburgh and Stornoway on Fridays.

The blame is being put on the Comhairle whose decision to pull the funding plug on Stornoway to Benbecula flights has been claimed to have left no plane available on Friday mornings for Stornoway to Edinburgh.

The islands’ SNP parliamentarians are pleading with the comhairle to reverse the decision, which Angus Macneil has described as part of the worst blow to transport services in 40 years.

According to Alasdair Allan MSP, the comhairle’s decision to stop funding Barra and Benbecula flights has now had consequences even for flights it didn’t even fund. Loganair says that with the Stornoway to Benbecula flights dropping down to three days a week, they have no plane available to run the seven am flight from Edinburgh to Stornoway on a Friday, or for the return from Stornoway to Edinburgh.

He said: “I declare an interest, inasmuch as I use the flight that Loganair are cancelling every week in life to return from Parliament. I have to say though that I will not be alone in being unimpressed. I am unclear whether the comhairle anticipated all this when they cut funding for Benbecula and Barra, but the consequence of their decision has been to diminish air services throughout the Western Isles as a whole.”

Meanwhile Angus MacNeil MP thought a lack of planning, by councillors who voted needlessly for the budget cut now appears to be impacting Stornoway, with two flights a week on Monday and Friday being cut from Stornoway to Inverness and the Friday morning from Stornoway to Edinburgh also being cut.

He said: “Due to the action taken by councillors, Stornoway links to Inverness are cut by 25% on a Monday and Friday to three flights per day, but on a Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday the normal service of four flights will remain.

“It had been projected that Stornoway would lose four flights from the cuts but the sum effect is that Stornoway is losing seven flights and the islands altogether are losing 21 flights.  This is as a result of the greatest single transport blow in 40 years that has unbelievable been administered by our own councillors with damage that seems to be increasing by the week.

“I would plead with them to think again, hopefully it is not too late for councillors who are meant to be independent to act for the good of the islands economy and back the plan put forward by SNP Councillors.”

Is the Barra flights petition just another stick to beat our democratically-elected council?

Kyles Flodda
Gramsdale
Isle of Benbecula

Dear Editor

More Heat than Light

I regret to have to say that my erstwhile colleagues in the SNP party, from MP, MSP and including also a number of councillors, are again guilty of an inglorious “own goal”. The wording of the Petition to the Scottish Government Petitions Committee is a knee-jerk reaction to a political decision on Inter-Island flights taken in good faith by the Comhairle, after extensive consultation at locality level, and is in my view inadmissible.

Quick reference to the Scottish Government guidance on submitting a Petition (4 pages of A4), states the following:

“A primary role of the PPC is to hold the Scottish Government to account. It has no remit to intervene in the operational decisions or actions of other public bodies in Scotland such as health boards and local authorities. A petition which requests the Parliament to do something it clearly has no power to do is inadmissible (page 2).”

Whilst it may be politically necessary to mobilise action in response to this decision of the Comhairle, it is a bit late in the day, and is at best foolhardy, at worst anarchic. Petitions should be embarked upon with a view to seeking a positive outcome, and not utilised as a big stick with which to beat the perceived offending council, democratically elected.

I believe your readers will have witnessed similar actions taken recently by our elected representatives with regard to – Road Equivalent Tariff (RET) with massive increases in fares for Commercial traffic, as imposed by the Minister, and more increases round the corner; School Closures, with upwards of an additional £1m being wasted because of delay in implementation, and the meter still ticking re legal action and fees; and of course cost of fuel, with inept political interventions to date (still paying 154.9p per litre for diesel in the Uists). All of these measures impact negatively on island residents.

This highlights for me the concerns we should all carry re the power struggle continuing between an SNP administration at Holyrood, bolstered on these islands by an SNP MP and MSP, and an independent council which is doing its level best to work within a much reduced budget, set by Holyrood.

I have previously written publicly about Inter-Island flights, and I have also communicated with respective Ministers, expressing the view that additional funding should be found from central government to enable continuation of inter-island flights, even with a reduced service, including the Barra to Benbecula route. The Western Isles Health Board received an additional funding of £1.7m only last week from the Minister for Health and Well Being. The Finance Secretary has a budget of over £30bn, the Comhairle has a budget of £117m. Where there’s a political will, a way can be found.

Our MP and MSP are, with respect, missing the target! Surely they are best placed to speak with the key SNP ministers at Holyrood who are budget holders, and work with the Comhairle to ensure essential life-line inter-island flights continue.

Any cursory glance at the workings of the Petitions Committee will quickly reach the conclusion that
(i) only competent petitions will be considered,
(ii) they are thorough and detailed in receiving evidence from all relevant parties, and
(iii) they don’t reach decisions quickly.

Western Isles Health Board are not likely to come to the aid of the Comhairle to share costs in subsidising air services, and comfort themselves in the knowledge that the Air Ambulance Service is available in any health emergency. This is short-sighted, and will incur massive increases in costs of emergency call-outs at £8000 + per flight: politicians from all parties should be alarmed at this prospect.

My advice to Dr Allan and Mr MacNeil is to reconsider your strategy, and please get on the phone with Ministers Keith Brown and John Swinney with a view to seeking additional temporary funding meantime to ensure continuation of flights from Barra to Benbecula, even if only for three days per week, linking in with the Benbecula to Stornoway connection. This will go some considerable way to allay immediate concerns and give the necessary time for a more detailed examination of inter-island flights across all remote locations, including Orkney and Shetland.

To help inject a level of common sense into this unfolding fiasco, I will again send a copy of this letter to Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon.

Yours faithfully

Andrew Walker